Abstract
This article examines the recent reform introduced by Law no. 1 of 7 January 2026 concerning the Italian Court of Auditors, with particular focus on access to the accounting judiciary and its systemic implications. Although the reform does not immediately alter existing recruitment procedures, it introduces guiding principles that potentially reshape the traditional foundations of the system, notably the unity of the judicial career and the functional interchangeability of roles.
The analysis highlights a tension between continuity and transformation. On the one hand, the reform appears to preserve the unitary structure of the accounting magistracy, grounded in a single competitive examination aimed at selecting generalist public law jurists. On the other hand, it introduces elements that may lead to a structural differentiation between prosecutorial (requirente) and adjudicative (giudicante) functions, particularly through the prohibition of functional transfers and the reference to access “also” to prosecutorial roles. This ambiguous formulation opens the way to a possible de facto separation of careers without an explicit constitutional revision.
A key innovation is the introduction of psychometric and aptitude-based assessments, aligned with recent developments in the ordinary judiciary. These tests, depending on their design, may serve either as neutral tools to enhance the overall quality of candidates or as mechanisms capable of orienting candidates toward specific functions from the outset, thus reinforcing functional differentiation.
The article further situates the reform within the broader evolution of the Court of Auditors’ functions, which increasingly require interdisciplinary expertise, particularly in economics and public finance. From this perspective, changes in recruitment may also be interpreted as an opportunity to redefine the professional profile of accounting magistrates, moving beyond a purely legalistic model toward a more integrated and technically competent judiciary.
Ultimately, the reform is characterised as problematic but not regressive. It raises significant issues of constitutional coherence and institutional balance, yet it may also strengthen the guarantees of independence, impartiality, and effectiveness of both jurisdictional and control functions. The decisive role will be played by the delegated legislation, which will have to strike a careful balance between unity and specialisation, ensuring consistency with the constitutional framework of Articles 100 and 103 of the Italian Constitution.
Full Text
PDFRiferimenti bibliografici
I contenuti redazionali di questo sito sono distribuiti con una licenza Creative Commons, Attribuzione - Condividi allo stesso modo 3.0 Italia (CC BY-SA 3.0 IT) eccetto dove diversamente specificato. Diretta da G. Terracciano, G. Mazzei, J. Espartero Casado. Direttore Responsabile: G. Caputi. Redazione: C. Rizzo. Iscritta al N. 16/2009 del Reg. stampa del Tribunale di Roma - ISSN 2036-7821
.
