Abstract
This article examines the sanctioning provisions introduced by Law no. 1 of 7 January 2026 within the Italian system of administrative liability before the Court of Auditors, focusing on their impact on the evolving nature of liability for damage to the public purse (responsabilità erariale). The reform introduces two main innovations: an ancillary sanction consisting of the temporary suspension from the management of public resources, and a pecuniary sanction for unjustified delays in procedures related to the implementation of the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP) and the complementary plan (PNC).
The analysis locates these measures within the broader transformation of administrative liability, increasingly characterised by a hybrid structure combining compensatory and punitive elements. Particular attention is devoted to the suspension measure, which raises significant issues concerning its legal nature, its compatibility with constitutional principles (including legality, proportionality and non-retroactivity), and its interaction with managerial accountability mechanisms. The provision appears to blur the traditional boundaries between judicial and administrative powers, potentially affecting the balance between jurisdictional functions and organisational autonomy.
The article further explores the pecuniary sanction for procedural delays, highlighting both its functional rationale—ensuring timely implementation of strategic public investments—and its practical and interpretative challenges, especially regarding the attribution of responsibility in complex administrative processes. The coexistence of sanctioning liability and traditional administrative liability also raises concerns about overlapping evaluations and possible “cascade effects” between different forms of responsibility.
More broadly, the reform is interpreted as reinforcing the sanctioning dimension of administrative liability, particularly through the reshaping of the judge’s power to reduce damages and the modification of limitation rules. These changes contribute to redefining liability before the Court of Auditors as a tertium genus, situated between civil compensation and punitive sanctioning regimes.
The article argues that, while the reform aims to enhance efficiency and accountability in the public administration, it introduces significant systemic tensions, requiring careful interpretation and possible judicial or legislative adjustments to ensure coherence with constitutional guarantees and European standards of due process.
Full Text
PDFRiferimenti bibliografici
I contenuti redazionali di questo sito sono distribuiti con una licenza Creative Commons, Attribuzione - Condividi allo stesso modo 3.0 Italia (CC BY-SA 3.0 IT) eccetto dove diversamente specificato. Diretta da G. Terracciano, G. Mazzei, J. Espartero Casado. Direttore Responsabile: G. Caputi. Redazione: C. Rizzo. Iscritta al N. 16/2009 del Reg. stampa del Tribunale di Roma - ISSN 2036-7821
.
