Saggi e contributi scientifici

Il controllo preventivo di legittimità


Abstract


This article examines the evolution and current configuration of preventive legality control exercised by the Italian Court of Auditors, with particular focus on the reforms introduced by Law no. 1/2026. Moving beyond the traditional act-based paradigm, the study locates preventive control within a broader transformation of administrative law toward a results-oriented model, in which oversight increasingly targets the whole administrative operation rather than isolated measures.

The analysis reconstructs the historical trajectory of preventive control, highlighting its shift from a generalised and often obstructive mechanism to a more selective instrument integrated with ex post performance evaluation and administrative liability. Particular attention is devoted to the so-called “protective effect” of preventive control, namely its capacity to exclude or mitigate liability for public officials in cases where acts have been positively reviewed.

The 2026 reform is critically assessed in light of constitutional case law, especially Constitutional Court judgment no. 132/2024. While the reform aligns with the need to reduce “defensive bureaucracy” and enhance administrative efficiency, it significantly expands both the scope of control—now extending to preparatory acts and entire administrative operations—and the exonerating effects linked to it, including in cases of tacit approval due to procedural time limits.

The article argues that this expansion generates a structural imbalance between the breadth of the protective effect and the actual effectiveness of judicial scrutiny, risking an excessive attenuation of administrative liability and a weakening of the principle of impartiality. Ultimately, the reform reflects a tension between efficiency and accountability, raising critical questions about the future balance of administrative control systems.

Full Text

PDF

Riferimenti bibliografici





I contenuti redazionali di questo sito sono distribuiti con una licenza Creative Commons, Attribuzione - Condividi allo stesso modo 3.0 Italia (CC BY-SA 3.0 IT) eccetto dove diversamente specificato. Diretta da G. Terracciano, G. Mazzei, J. Espartero Casado. Direttore Responsabile: G. Caputi. Redazione: C. Rizzo. Iscritta al N. 16/2009 del Reg. stampa del Tribunale di Roma - ISSN 2036-7821